The glistening ice, clear white trays, and colourful filets behind your grocery retailer seafood counter are designed to look pristine and reliable. However beneath the floor of that clear presentation, there’s a world of deception, questionable sourcing, and unsafe practices that may make most customers suppose twice.
Seafood is among the most complicated and poorly regulated classes within the international meals provide, and sadly, your native grocery store is usually floor zero for lots of the business’s worst habits.
From pretend fish to chemical remedies and seafood with a passport longer than yours, listed here are 9 alarming truths hiding in plain sight behind the seafood counter and what you should know to guard your pockets, your well being, and your conscience.
1. You Would possibly Not Be Shopping for the Fish You Assume You Are
Seafood fraud is rampant. In line with a research by Oceana, 1 in 5 seafood samples globally is mislabeled, with cheaper or lower-quality fish substituted for dearer ones. At your grocery store, that “wild-caught pink snapper” would possibly really be tilapia or rockfish. Or that expensive “sea bass” could possibly be a completely completely different species with no resemblance in taste or diet.
Why does this occur? As a result of as soon as a fish is filleted and skinned, even skilled eyes have bother telling them aside. Unscrupulous suppliers and middlemen benefit from this to cross off low-cost fish underneath premium names, particularly in frozen, pre-packaged, or bulk choices.
2. “Contemporary” Fish Is Typically Beforehand Frozen
If a seafood label says “recent,” you most likely image a latest catch. However in lots of circumstances, that fish was frozen at sea, then thawed for show simply earlier than it hit the seafood counter. There’s nothing inherently flawed with freezing fish—it might probably protect vitamins and texture fairly properly. The issue is when supermarkets don’t disclose it and cost premium costs for a product that’s already been defrosted days (and even weeks) earlier than.
Search for phrases like “beforehand frozen,” “refreshed,” or “might have been frozen for transport” on wonderful print close to the worth tag, or ask your fishmonger immediately. In the event that they hesitate or don’t know, contemplate {that a} pink flag. You could be overpaying for a defrosted product with a shorter shelf life and unknowingly bringing house fish that’s already on the clock.
3. Imported Fish Typically Comes From Questionable Farms
About 90% of the seafood bought in U.S. grocery shops is imported, and a big portion of that comes from fish farms in international locations with little to no environmental or security oversight. In elements of Southeast Asia, as an illustration, farmed shrimp and tilapia are sometimes raised in polluted waters and crowded situations and fed with antibiotics, hormones, and even animal feces. These contaminated environments have been linked to antibiotic-resistant micro organism and harmful pathogens.
Due to lax laws, these fish can cross by means of international provide chains and land in your dinner plate with out you ever realizing the true situations of their origin. Imported fish would possibly carry greater than taste. It may include antibiotics, heavy metals, and unsafe micro organism that U.S. meals legal guidelines would by no means enable.
4. Carbon Monoxide Is Used to “Freshen” Fish Coloration
That lovely, vibrant pink tuna steak at your native grocery store? It would owe its brilliant hue to not freshness however to carbon monoxide gasoline. This gasoline is typically utilized in packaging tuna and different fish to lock in coloration, making previous fish look more energizing than it really is. It doesn’t protect style or security, simply look. Actually, fish handled this manner might scent wonderful however be dangerously spoiled inside.
Whereas authorized within the U.S. with correct labeling, many grocers fail to reveal carbon monoxide use or depend on distributors who use it earlier than cargo.
5. Glazing and Weight Padding Are Widespread Pricing Tips
Glazing is the method of coating frozen fish in ice to forestall freezer burn. It’s regular up to a degree, however in lots of grocery chains, over-glazing is used to inflate weight and pad revenue margins. In some circumstances, as much as 30% of the fish’s whole weight is simply ice. Which means whenever you pay by the pound, an excellent chunk of your cash is actually happening the drain as quickly as you thaw it. Some shops even pump water or sodium-based options into filets to spice up weight and provides fish a falsely tender texture, additional distorting worth and diet.
6. Many Fish Are Excessive in Mercury and Heavy Metals
Sure fish, particularly bigger predatory species like tuna, swordfish, shark, and king mackerel, include dangerously excessive ranges of mercury—a neurotoxin that accumulates over time and might affect mind operate, particularly in youngsters and pregnant girls. Even smaller species like Chilean sea bass or grouper can carry excessive ranges of PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) and arsenic, relying on their area of origin.
But many supermarkets fail to publish mercury warning indicators or educate prospects about safer options—leaving shoppers to unknowingly feed their households doubtlessly hazardous meals.
7. Sustainable Choices Are Hardly ever Labeled Clearly
Whereas many consumers attempt to make eco-conscious selections, grocery retailer seafood counters usually make that tough. Phrases like “wild-caught” and “farm-raised” don’t inform the total story, and most shops fail to point which fish are responsibly sourced or licensed by teams just like the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) or Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC).
Sustainable seafood sourcing is complicated and varies broadly by species and area. But few seafood counters present particulars about fishing strategies, bycatch dangers, or environmental affect, forcing customers to depend on obscure advertising and marketing slightly than info. With out correct labeling, even well-intentioned shoppers might find yourself supporting harmful fishing practices and unsustainable farms.
8. Parasites and Micro organism Are Extra Widespread Than You Assume
In contrast to beef or poultry, seafood is usually consumed uncooked or flippantly cooked—suppose sushi, ceviche, or seared tuna. Nonetheless, what most shoppers don’t understand is that uncooked seafood from supermarkets carries a excessive danger of parasites and pathogens.
-
Anisakis worms in undercooked wild salmon
-
Listeria and Vibrio micro organism in oysters and shellfish
-
Hepatitis A outbreaks linked to imported scallops or clams
Whereas respected sushi eating places freeze their fish to kill parasites, most grocery store seafood doesn’t meet the identical requirements, making uncooked consumption far riskier. Until you’re 100% certain of its sourcing and dealing with, grocery store seafood ought to at all times be absolutely cooked to keep away from severe sickness.
9. Some “Wild-Caught” Labels Are Flat-Out False
Customers usually search out “wild-caught” fish, believing it’s more healthy, extra sustainable, or higher tasting. However identical to “natural” or “pure,” the time period “wild-caught” is regularly misused—or outright fabricated. A 2019 NOAA investigation discovered a number of situations of farm-raised fish being bought as wild-caught, particularly in species like salmon, catfish, and even crab. With out constant third-party verification, it’s extremely tough to substantiate a fish’s true origin simply by wanting on the label.
Much more troubling: the typical grocery retailer worker might do not know the place the fish got here from or what’s behind the model title printed on the sticker.
So What Can You Do? Smarter Seafood Buying Begins Right here
Whereas all of this will likely sound discouraging, it doesn’t imply it’s important to swear off seafood utterly. Listed below are a number of sensible tricks to store smarter and shield your well being:
- Ask Querys – Discuss to the seafood counter attendant. Ask the place the fish got here from, whether or not it was beforehand frozen, and whether or not it’s been handled with carbon monoxide or components.
- Examine for Certification Labels – Search for labels from MSC, ASC, or Greatest Aquaculture Practices (BAP). These point out stronger requirements in sustainability and security.
- Purchase from Respected Fishmongers or Specialty Market – If attainable, store from native markets specializing in seafood. They usually have higher sourcing transparency and more energizing merchandise.
- Use On-line Seafood Information – Assets just like the Monterey Bay Aquarium’s Seafood Watch app may also help you establish protected, sustainable selections on the grocery retailer.
- When in Doubt, Cook dinner Totally – Keep away from consuming uncooked grocery store seafood until it’s labeled “sushi-grade,” and also you’re assured within the retailer’s dealing with practices.
Know What You’re Actually Bringing House
The seafood counter would possibly seem like a clear, protected haven of recent ocean taste, however as we’ve seen, it usually hides layers of murky practices. From mislabeling and chemical tips to contamination and sustainability considerations, your grocery retailer fish could possibly be a far cry from what you suppose you’re shopping for.
The excellent news? Consciousness is energy. Armed with the fitting questions and a essential eye, you’ll be able to nonetheless get pleasure from scrumptious seafood with out the hidden risks or hidden charges.
Have you ever ever found one thing sketchy on the seafood counter or had a fishy shopping for expertise that made you swear off grocery store seafood?
Learn Extra:
10 Eye-Opening Truths About Rotisserie Chickens Roasting Below These Warmth Lamps
The way to Consider Well being Data On-line
Riley is an Arizona native with over 9 years of writing expertise. From private finance to journey to digital advertising and marketing to popular culture, she’s written about every little thing underneath the solar. When she’s not writing, she’s spending her time outdoors, studying, or cuddling along with her two corgis.
